Unsurprisingly , someone onReddithas stirred up quite the debate — and this meter , it has to do with your accommodation preference when you ’re on holiday .

It was a serene morning on r / Travel when someone decided to open Pandora ’s box and ask the always - factious question . " Why do you opt a refuge / villa / air bnb / hotel ? " one user asked . " Finally I know I make love an adult - only resort because I enjoy being around people but not children . I feel like a villa / air bnb particularly when it ’s just two people is too quiet . Why do you love or hate any of the above ? "

Many opinionated traveler answered the call , and the yarn quickly became a very utile cock for all those who somehow still have to form an opinion on the matter . Which add us here — if you are still disordered whether a hotel is good than an Airbnb or other vacation letting , then look no further . We gather the top responses for each , and laid them out here highlight the most popular pros and cons ( according to Redditors ) to help you make up your mind .

hotel

Thomas Barwick/DigitalVision/Getty Images

Pros and cons of hotels and resorts

Some the great unwashed likehotelsjust because of everything theyare not . According to the very top comment in the thread , hotels are right because , unlike all - inclusive resorts , there are scummy chances of you eating and drinking poorly . " Nice to have the endless beers do to you at [ the ] pool or beach . Food whenever you want it , " register the comment referring to a preceding experience at an all - inclusive stamping ground . " On the other hand , bartenders had no melodic theme on how to mix a drink . Food always come out of the hotel kitchens very quick , so I ’d acquire it was all pre - made , and that ’s not going to be great food . "

One disceptation against that dissertation is that it really depends on the refuge you ’re stick at , and sometimes you might just get ill-starred . But another argument in favor of hotels , instead , is much unattackable . " Not interested in someone else ’s habitation , " reads another comment supporting the hotel selection . " Not interested in cooking on vacation . " Another exploiter point out that when you ’re staying in a hotel , you are not required to really strip up after yourself — which , at times , is outline as an outlook of the hosts of some holiday rentals .

Plus , hotels and their staff can help you 24/7 — and the more you come back , the more they reward you . " I wish hotels . I basically want a place to kip , " reads another comment . " If I need anything I call the front desk . I used to go a lot for work so there is actually some real value in hotel awards programs . [ I ] have gotten some free nights at some really nice properties . "

Pros and cons of Airbnbs and vacation rentals

Other sept will insteaddefend Airbnbsandother vacation rentalsat all costs .

First of all , there is the localfeelan Airbnb give you compare to a hotel . " I care Airbnbs because they experience much more real than a generic hotel , " take one comment . " I can get a whole apartment in a real neighborhood in a city [ and ] get a feel for what subsist in a dissimilar city is really like . I also wish the spare quad and give birth a kitchen to prepare if I want to save money . " Plus , while this is n’t always true , Airbnbs tend to be " cheaper than hotel elbow room of equal niceness , " as one Redditor put it .

harmonise to some Reddit users , those who had damaging experience with Airbnb simply did n’t do enough research beforehand . " We spend a wad of clock time search , read brushup etc . , " said one Redditor . " We just like plan and have not had a bad experience . I like having my own space and have found some decent spots in parts of cities where you ca n’t get a hotel . "

And as vacation rental supporters will have you live , Airbnbs and other vacation rentals come with many perks — let in a much more laid - back and exemption - orient lifestyle . " Depending on the renting , you have individual amenities , unexclusive kitchen and infrigidation entree , patio place and arrant privacy in general , " remark one user . " you could make noise without trouble ( within ground ) . you may fudge . You do n’t have to apportion the pocket billiards . It ’s much more conducive to that style of repose back , private grouping vibration than hotels or resorts are . "

So , which side are you on ? Team Hotel or Team Airbnb ?